The digital brand handbook from MerkBrouwers

Consistency is not a detail.

Seventeen studies and seven scientific publications show what a consistent brand delivers, and what it costs when brand files get scattered.

At a glance

+32 pp

higher revenue growth at companies that manage design best

MeasuredSource [12]

81%

say trust in a brand is a deciding factor in a purchase

2 hours

a day spent by employees looking for documents, information or people

30%

say their brand guidelines are widely known and used

How to read the figures

Every figure has a label, so you can see how strong the evidence is.

Measured
Based on measured behaviour, stock market data or an analysis of campaigns.
Survey
What respondents themselves report or expect.
Estimate
An estimate or model by analysts.
01

Consistency drives revenue

Companies themselves expect more revenue from a consistent brand, and hard business data points the same way.

What does this mean?

One fixed source for your brand makes consistency the standard, not a matter of luck.

Read the deep dive

+32 pp

higher revenue growth over five years at companies that manage design best, compared with industry peers.

MeasuredSource [12]

2×

as likely to exceed growth goals for companies with a strong brand strategy.

10–20%

more revenue is what organisations expect if their brand were consistent everywhere.

33%

average revenue growth brand managers expected in 2019 from a consistently managed brand.

02

Recognition builds trust

People choose a brand they know and trust more quickly. And marketers often judge that recognition too optimistically.

What does this mean?

Recognition only happens when everyone always uses the same logos, colours and fonts.

Read the deep dive

81%

say trust in a brand is a deciding factor in a purchase.

80%

trust the brands they use. Trust now weighs as much as quality and price.

60%

prefer to buy new products from a brand they already know.

73%

of marketers’ estimates overstated how well known their own brand assets are.

MeasuredSource [10]

72%

of those estimates understated how uniquely the brand assets are linked to their own brand.

MeasuredSource [10]

2%

of marketers’ estimates came within 5 percentage points of what consumers actually recognised.

MeasuredSource [10]
03

Searching costs hours every week

When files are scattered across email, folders and colleagues, a lot of time goes into searching and duplicate work.

What does this mean?

When everything is in one place, you find the right file in seconds instead of hours.

Read the deep dive

2 hours

per day, at least a quarter of the work week, spent looking for documents, information or people.

almost 2/3

say they spend too much time searching for information.

~20%

of knowledge workers’ week goes to looking for internal information or the right colleague.

EstimateSource [4]

26%

have created something that later turned out to exist already.

60%

of working time goes to work about work: searching, coordinating and status updates instead of the actual work.

04

Off-brand content is the rule rather than the exception

The more colleagues, agencies and freelancers work with a brand, the more often something goes out that isn't right.

What does this mean?

Give colleagues, agencies and freelancers access to the right version, and less goes wrong.

Read the deep dive

81%

of organisations dealt with off-brand content in 2019.

77%

say they create off-brand content at least a few times a year.

05

Guidelines only work if they are findable

Almost every company has a style guide or templates. But a guideline nobody can find doesn't get used.

What does this mean?

A living online brand handbook does get used, because it is easy to find and always up to date.

Read the deep dive

30%

say their brand guidelines are well known and used by most of the organisation.

13%

have guidelines that aren’t used or can’t be found. Another 15% have none at all.

16%

uses creative templates across the whole organisation, while 92% do have templates.

60–70%

of B2B marketing content went unused, according to an estimate by SiriusDecisions.

EstimateSource [9]
06

Brand building takes staying power

A consistent brand doesn’t pay for itself in one campaign, but over years. Analyses of campaigns, share prices and buying behaviour show why.

What does this mean?

See your brand as an investment: using the same distinctive elements for years builds value that lasts.

Read the deep dive

60:40

is the best split between brand building and direct activation, according to 996 campaigns.

MeasuredSource [13]

43%

of emotional brand campaigns showed very large profit effects after three years or more, against 23% of rational ones.

MeasuredSource [13]

95%

of B2B buyers are not in the market right now. Your brand needs to be remembered until they do buy.

EstimateSource [14]

Since 2006

shares of companies with the strongest brands have consistently outperformed the market average.

MeasuredSource [15]

84%

of companies under-measure their brand and therefore also underfund it.

Why consistency works

The figures above don’t stand alone. Six insights from marketing science and psychology explain why a brand that looks the same everywhere is stronger.

Signalling theory

A brand is a promise you have to keep again and again

Customers know less about your product than you do, so they look for signals they can trust. Erdem and Swait showed that a brand only becomes credible when those signals are consistent and clear. That lowers perceived risk and makes customers less price-sensitive. Mixed messages weaken the signal.

Erdem & Swait (1998)

Processing fluency

What is easy to process feels trustworthy

The brain uses ease as a rule of thumb: what is recognised quickly feels familiar, true and pleasant, as Reber, Schwarz and Winkielman showed. A different colour, a stretched logo or a shifted tone creates small friction. That friction makes people look more critically, which rarely works in your favour.

Reber, Schwarz & Winkielman (2004)

Mental availability

Distinctive brand assets have to wear into memory

According to the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, brands grow mainly by coming to mind at the moment of purchase. Logos, colours and typefaces act as memory hooks. Romaniuk describes how those hooks only get strong when used consistently over a long time. Keep showing something different and you start from scratch every time.

Sharp (2010); Romaniuk (2018)

Brand dilution

Inconsistency blurs what your brand stands for

Loken and Roedder John studied how brand beliefs weaken. When expressions don’t fit together, associations with your brand become vaguer. Sloppy or outdated materials can also suggest lower quality that reflects on the whole brand.

Loken & Roedder John (1993)

Consumer confusion

Conflicting signals lead to delay

Walsh, Hennig-Thurau and Mitchell describe how conflicting or overly varied information confuses people. Those who doubt postpone decisions more often, or choose an alternative that comes across as calmer and clearer.

Walsh, Hennig-Thurau & Mitchell (2007)

Effectiveness

Brand effects build up over years

Binet and Field analysed nearly a thousand campaigns from the IPA databank. Activation drives sales quickly, but that effect also fades quickly. Brand building works more slowly, but it accumulates: the brand gets stronger and customers become less price sensitive. They saw the best results at roughly 60% brand and 40% activation.

Binet & Field (2013)

The conclusion in six lines

  1. 01

    One fixed source for your brand makes consistency the standard, not a matter of luck.

  2. 02

    Recognition only happens when everyone always uses the same logos, colours and fonts.

  3. 03

    When everything is in one place, you find the right file in seconds instead of hours.

  4. 04

    Give colleagues, agencies and freelancers access to the right version, and less goes wrong.

  5. 05

    A living online brand handbook does get used, because it is easy to find and always up to date.

  6. 06

    See your brand as an investment: using the same distinctive elements for years builds value that lasts.

Sources

We only cite figures that can be found on the source page itself. Click a title to open the source.

  1. [1]
    State of Brand Consistency 2021

    Lucidpress, survey of over 450 respondents, 2021

    Survey2021
  2. [2]
    Survey: Brand Consistency Can Boost Sales

    ASI Central on the Lucidpress State of Brand Consistency report, more than 200 organisations, 2019

    Survey2019
  3. [3]
    Are Businesses Creating and Using Brand Guidelines?

    MarketingProfs, based on a Lucidpress survey of 452 professionals

    Survey2021
  4. [4]
    Estimate2012
  5. [5]
    Hybrid Workplace Habits & Hangups: Employees Spend a Quarter of Workweek Searching for Information

    The Harris Poll for Glean, 1,043 employed adults in the US, December 2021

    Survey2021
  6. [6]
    Anatomy of Work Index 2021

    Asana and Sapio Research, 13,123 knowledge workers, October 2020

    Survey2021
  7. [7]
    Only One-Third of Consumers Trust Most of the Brands They Buy

    Edelman Trust Barometer Special Report: In Brands We Trust?, 16,000 consumers in eight countries, June 2019

    Survey2019
  8. [8]
    Global Survey of New Product Purchase Sentiment

    Nielsen, more than 29,000 online consumers in 58 countries, 2012 (via MarketingCharts)

    Survey2012
  9. [9]
    My Three Biggest “Aha” Moments (So Far)

    SiriusDecisions (now Forrester), analyst estimate, around 2014

    Estimate2014
  10. [10]
    Assessing branding strength: comparing marketer judgement and consumer data for brand identity elements

    Ehrenberg-Bass Institute in the Journal of Brand Management: 405 brand assets from 50 brands, 7,505 consumers and 157 marketers in seven countries, 2025

    Measured2025
  11. [11]
    2025 Edelman Trust Barometer Special Report: Brand Trust, From We to Me

    Edelman, 15,000 respondents in 15 countries, April–May 2025

    Survey2025
  12. [12]
    The business value of design

    McKinsey & Company, 300 listed companies tracked over five years, October 2018

    Measured2018
  13. [13]
    The Long and the Short of It

    Les Binet and Peter Field for the IPA, analysis of 996 campaigns from 700 brands in 83 categories, 2013

    Measured2013
  14. [14]
    The 95:5 rule is the new 60:40 rule

    Peter Weinberg and Jon Lombardo (LinkedIn’s B2B Institute) in Marketing Week, based on work by John Dawes (Ehrenberg-Bass Institute), September 2021

    Estimate2021
  15. [15]
    Using Kantar BrandZ to make the case for long-term brand-building investment

    Kantar BrandZ, share price performance of the most valuable brands since 2006, October 2024

    Measured2024
  16. [16]
    Gartner Marketing Survey Finds 84% of Companies Are Stuck in a Brand Doom Loop

    Gartner, 426 senior marketing leaders, September–October 2025, published June 2026

    Survey2026
  17. [17]
    These 3 charts from Microsoft show why technology is making your job harder

    World Economic Forum on the Microsoft Work Trend Index 2023, around 31,000 workers in 31 countries, August 2023

    Survey2023

Academic literature

Survey figures show what respondents themselves report or expect, not a measured effect. Some studies are a few years old; we always state the year, so you can judge how current a figure is.

Curious about how your brand is doing?

Put your brand into MarkBase free for 30 days, or request a demo first in which we look together at where you lose time and consistency.